Four months of publishing, and no way to tell what it produced
Our contact form recorded the same origin for every enquiry. The field that existed to tell them apart told them apart from nothing — and you only find out when you ask.
Four months of publishing, and no way to tell what it produced
Two days before our publishing calendar started, we found something in our own system that would have made four months of work unmeasurable.
Our contact form records where each enquiry came from. That field exists to tell them apart: did this person arrive through an article, a search engine, LinkedIn, or directly? It turned out to hold the same value for everyone — the literal text "contact-form". Every enquiry, every time.
The field that existed to make a distinction made none at all.
Why nobody noticed
Because nothing broke. Enquiries arrived, were emailed, were stored, and appeared neatly in the overview. Every individual step did exactly what it was supposed to do.
It was only the question you ask six months later — which piece actually produced this conversation? — that had no answer. And you only ask that question once you need it.
That is the treacherous thing about measurement: a missing measurement produces no error. It produces an empty cell, and an empty cell looks like "nothing has happened here yet" rather than "this was never written down".
Why it could not wait
We could have picked this up calmly in January. That even looked sensible: publish first, see whether anyone turns up, and start measuring once there is something to measure.
That reasoning fails for one reason. Attribution does not work retroactively. Someone who arrives through an article in September and leaves their details leaves a trace at that moment — or does not. Build the measurement in January and September through December are not hard to measure, they are gone. Four months of work you will never be able to account for.
That turned it into a day's work with a deadline rather than an improvement for later.
What we changed
The origin now travels all the way through to the customer record. An article that links to the contact form names itself in that link: it knows which article it is, and by the time someone submits the form, the referring page only knows they came from the contact page. So the article has to identify itself, or the connection is lost for good.
Where that is missing, the system falls back on the page someone came from. And where that is missing too, it records "direct" — an honest answer instead of an invented source.
On top of that, every lead now carries an estimated value, a next action with a date, and a reason when it is lost. A list of names and statuses is not a pipeline; you cannot total it and you cannot schedule it.
What you can check yourself
You do not need to be a developer for this. Three questions, and the answers tell you enough:
Of your last ten enquiries, can you say where each one came from? Not "through the website" — that is the bus, not the stop. Which article, which service, which channel.
What is a customer worth to you, and is that written down anywhere? Without an amount you cannot say whether your effort produced anything, only that something happened.
What is the next step on your three most important open conversations, and when? If the answer is "I need to chase that", then that is the answer.
Anyone who answers these three easily has their house in order. Anyone who has to think about it now knows where the first day of work is.
What this is not
Attribution is not truth. Someone sees you on LinkedIn, thinks about it for two weeks, then searches for your name and arrives as "direct". Our system dutifully records "direct", which is factually correct and substantively misleading. The last step takes the credit for the whole path.
So do not expect accounting from it. What it does give you is a rough direction where there was none: which subject produces conversations and which channel produces only visits. That is enough to decide where your next hour goes — and that was the question all along.
Share this article
Curious what is possible?
One conversation is usually enough to tell whether it fits. A reply within 24 hours, and no middlemen.